Electric Cars
Garage tinkerers have been turning hybrids into plug-ins for years, but somehow
no one paid attention. Other clean-car alternatives got all the love. But,
really-hydrogen? Maybe, someday. Now, the carmakers say plug-ins are coming, if
the engineers can get the batteries right. They will. Because it's hard to argue
with 100 mpg.
The
110-Volt Solution
The future of American
motoring can be found in any hardware store.
It's not in the automotive section, but over in the power tools aisle. There it
sits, proudly displayed as the newest must-have tool in DIY America: the
high-powered cordless drill. It's the battery we're interested in, a lithium-ion
pack so densely charged with energy that a new 28-volt power pack is slimmer
than an older 18-volt nickel-metal-hydride (NiMH) battery. In just over a year,
li-ion completed a leap from cellphones to power tools and grabbed the spotlight
in that market. Now its boosters say
the battery is preparing to graduate to the big time, 4 million miles of
American road.
That
is the vision articulated by automotive executives, shade-tree Prius hackers,
Department of Energy officials and-especially-budding battery impresarios such
as Ric Fulop. To hear Fulop tell it, electric motors powered by li-ion batteries
are the future. Specifically, his batteries. Fulop is always excitable, but he
really starts to rev up when the talk turns to plug-in hybrid electric vehicles,
or PHEVs—and he makes sure the subject
comes up often. Then he tends to cut loose with a "Dude!" As in: "Dude! We're
getting 7000 charge cycles." Or: "Dude! Have you
driven
an electric car?"
Fulop, age 32, is a vice president at
A123S.ystems, a Watertown, Mass., purveyor of li-ion batteries that hopes to
capture a sizeable chunk of what could turn into a $6 billion PHEV battery
market. An MIT graduate, Fulop co-founded A123 in 2001 with a $100,000 grant
from the Department of Energy. Today, his company is the sole supplier of li-ion
batteries to Black & Decker and is working with automakers to develop a mass
production PHEV. Unlike conventional hybrids-say, the Toyota Prius or Ford
Escape Hybridthese vehicles could be charged from a home outlet and then driven
for up to 40 miles on electricity before the gas engine ever turned over. Now,
A123 is locked in a race with a handful of other firms filled with young,
caffeinated Ph.D.s geeking out over cathodes and anodes and lithium in an
attempt to engineer the biggest shift in car technology since the advent of the
combustion engine.
This community of go-getting chemists and
engineers got an adrenaline infusion in January when General Motors unveiled a
plug-in concept car at the Detroit auto show. With its angular lines, sleek
interior and 120-mph top speed, the Volt-meant to show off a new PHEV system
called E-Flex-was inspiring. It was the first hybrid to suggest that efficiency
can offer more than the smug satisfaction of virtue; it can be downright fun.
"Dude!" Fulop says. "This is gonna be so huge!"
Finding an Outlet
Today, there are more than 230 million cars
and trucks in the United States, of which maybe 700,000 have some form of
electric motor to help drive the wheels. That's one-third of one percent-hardly
the makings of an electric-car revolution. On the other hand, whether they focus
on focus on hybrids, pure electrics, hydrogen, ethanol, clean diesel or another
concept, nearly every carmaker is betting R & D dollars that conventional
powertrains soon will face real competition from more efficient,
climate-friendly technologies.
The PHEV's main selling point is big fuel economy, using technology that's
almost ready now. While hydrogen, in particular, would demand new
infrastructure on a grand scale,
plug-ins rely on 110-volt home powerlines and pump gasoline. Tinkerers such as
Felix Kramer, founder of PHEV advocacy group California Cars Initiative, already
get 100 mpg on 55-mile trips using cobbled-together PHEVs.
Such fuel economy is within reach for anyone
with a conventional hybrid, good mechanical skills and around $5000 to spend on
parts-Kramer and friends are happy to help with advice and plans. Soon, drivers
may be able to pay an aftermarket outfit to do the work. Both Hymotion, a
Toronto company, and California-based EDrive Systems convert stock hybrids to
PHEVs for fleet clients, at $12,000 a pop. The companies say they want to start
offering the service to everyday road warriors-Hymotion by the end of 2007.
Hybrids Plus, a new company in Boulder, Colo., hopes to start doing conversions
by this summer.
Factory-built, dealer-sold PHEVs are another story. General Motors says both an
E-Flex car and a Saturnbranded plug-in, called the Vue Green Line, will be
ready by 2010. The Vue, like models on the roads now, will follow a "parallel"
design, in which both an electric motor and a gasoline engine drive the wheels,
often working in concert. In contrast, the E-Flex cars will be "series"
hybrids. Only the electric motor will turn the wheels.
WATTS TO DRIVE?
Hybrid cars such as the
Toyota Prius may soon be joined on the road by plug-in hybrids and pure
electrics. Here are the specs on some distinct approaches to building such cars.
The key figure may be the cost to go 30 miles, a typical U.S. round-trip
commute. For comparison with a conventional gas-powered model, that figure for a
2007 Toyota Camry would be $2.83.
Reported by Emily Masamitsu
TOYOTA PRIUS
HOW IT WORKS
The Prius is driven by a 76-hp
gasoline engine supplemented by a 50-kw, 28-hp electric motor.
BATTERIES
201.6-volt, 1.3-kwh NiMH
SOURCES OF ELECTRICITY
Batteries store energy generated
during braking and are fed by a generator coupled to the engine.
RANGE
600-plus miles
FUEL ECONOMY
60 city/51 highway
COST FOR 30-MILE TRIP*
$1.39 ($.046 per mile)
COST FOR 200-MILE TRIP
$9.27
($.046 per mile)
AVAILABILITY Toyota has
sold some 700,000 Priuses worldwide since introducing the car in Japan
in 1997. Last year, it sold 107,000 in the United States.
PRICE $22,175 (base) |
HYMOTION PLUG-IN PRIUS
HOW IT WORKS Several
approaches are used to convert stock hybrids to plug-ins.
Hymotion integrates a charge port and an additional battery into a
Prius.
BATTERIES Stock 201.6-volt, 1.3-kwh NiMH, plus a 5-kwh li-ion
SOURCES OF ELECTRICITY 110-volt outlet, plus the stock Prius
combination of regenerative braking and an on-board generator
RANGE 630-plus miles
FUEL ECONOMY 200-plus mpg city/100 mpg highway for the first
30 miles; then 60/51
AVAILABILITY Currently only for fleet customers; consumer
sales should start in 2007.
COST FOR 30-MILE TRIP*
$1.01 ($.034 per mile)
COST FOR 200-MILE TRIP
$8.86 ($.044 per mile)
PRICE Below $32,175 (Prius, plus up to $10,000 for consumer
conversion) |
TESLA ROADSTER
HOW IT WORKS The Tesla is a pure electric vehicle with a
185-kw, 248-hp motor.
BATTERIES 375-Volt, 56-kwh li-ion
SOURCES OF ELECTRICITY The Tesla charges off a 110-volt or
220-volt electric line; the car also converts braking energy into
electricity.
RANGE 250 miles (based on EPA highway mileage regime)
FUEL ECONOMY Not applicable
AVAILABILITY Tesla plans to ship its first 100 Roadsters in
the fall of 2007.
COST FOR 30-MILE TRIP*
$.66 ($.022 per mile)
COST FOR 200-MILE TRIP
$4.40 ($.022 per mile)
PRICE $92,950 (base) |
GM VOLT
HOW IT WORKS E-Flex vehicles such as the Volt will drive their
wheels with a 120-kw, 160-hp electric motor. An engine or fuel
cell will run an on-board electric generator.
BATTERIES 320- to 350- volt, 16-kwh li-ion
SOURCES OF ELECTRICITY 110-volt outlet; engine-powered
generator (Future E-Drive vehicles may use other power sources, such as
a fuel cell, to drive the generator.)
RANGE** 640 miles
FUEL ECONOMY 50 mpg
AVAILABILITY General Motors plans to release its first E-Flex
vehicles as early as 2010.
COST FOR 30-MILE TRIP*
$.63 ($.021 per mile)
COST FOR 200-MILE TRIP
$9.00 ($.045 per mile)
PRICE Below $30,000 |
Typical U.S. round-trip commute based on U.S. DOT
statistics. All cost estimates assume $2.55/gal. gasoline,
$6.1055/kilowatt hour / (kwh) electricity**GM
Volt range, fuel economy, cost figures and price are estimates based on
General Motors |

The First Issue is Durability
Typically, makers of
hybrid cars guarantee their batteries for at least eight years or 80,000 miles.
In states that follow California's standards for Partial Zero Emissions
Vehicles, the figures are 10 years and 150,000 miles. Those are high standards
for li-ion batteries (think how poorly a three-year-old laptop battery performs)
and it's hard to predict how long newly developed units will last. Small
operations such as Hymotion can offer shorter warranty periods, but big
caretakers want to bring vehicles to market that meet or beat today's standards.
Then, there's the matter of safety.
Remember those exploding laptop batteries that made headlines last year? In a
computer, a burning battery is bad; in a car, it's a disaster.
A123, which has a contract
to develop a battery for GM, is not the only outfit reporting progress; Reno,
Nevada-based Altair Nanotechnologies is shipping li-ion polymer packs to Phoenix
Motorcars for the company's pure electric vehicles, which can travel 100 miles
on a charge. (Currently, Phoenix, a small California firm, is selling to a few
fleet customers; it plans to introduce a consumer model in 2008.) Saft, a
French company, is also working on a battery for GM.
|